Recommended link to article:
KONSTANTIN ANATOLYEVICH SOLOVIEVа
аLomonosov Moscow State University
DOI: 10.22394/2070-8378-2021-23-1-79-88
Abstract:
The article examines the views of Count B.Ch. Minich on the nature and mechanism of state government. The article examines the thoughts of this statesman about the goals and nature of governance, correlates his theoretical views with management practice, analyzes proposals to change the system of public administration and civil service. The author uses historical and textual analysis (semantic, terminological, and discursive) in combination with the method of historical and situational analysis. Particular attention is paid to the concept of “emptiness” in public administration, which is fundamental for the theoretical studies of Count Minich. As a result of the analysis, it is concluded that “emptiness” means the absence of a system for making government decisions and their implementation. According to Minich, the main consequence of this problem was the strengthening of the influence of the Empress’s favorites, and as for the country, there was nothing good in this at all. To remedy the situation, Minich suggested implementing “rational bureaucracy”, which was expressed in his proposals to institutionalize the governance system, introduce stable procedures, rely on laws, and not use personal relationships to conduct the country’s affairs. Minich adhered to functional, rational, and bureaucratic (procedural) principles of governing. He believed that the imperfection of the monarchical way of government (“emptiness” in governance) could be corrected through the above-mentioned transformations and relying on those persons who have such qualities as honesty, diligence, etc.
Keywords:
civil service, history of public administration, history of governance thought, XVIII century, Minich, Anna Ioannovna, Elizaveta Petrovna, Catherine II
Received:
December 1, 2020
References:
Anisimov E.V. Ivan VI Antonovich. Moscow: Molodaya gvardiya, 2008. In Russian
Bantysh-Kamensky D. Biographies of Russian Generalissimo and General-Field Marshals. Part 1. St. Petersburg, 1840. P. 177-202. In Russian
Bestuzhev-Ryumin K.N. Foreword // Notes of Field Marshal Count Minich. Ed. by Shubinsky S. N. St. Petersburg: Tip. Bezobrazova i komp, 1874. In Russian
Weber Max. Economy and society: Essays on interpretive sociology. Volume 4. Moscow: Izdatel’skiy dom Vysshey shkoly ekonomiki, 2019. In Russian
Hobbes T. Leviathan. Moscow: Mysl’, 2001. In Russian
Grotius H. On the law of war and peace. Book one. http://www. civisbook.ru/files/File/Groziy.Kn1.pdf Dosuzheva E.E., Kirillov Yu.V. Rational approach to managerial decision making. Idei i idealy. 2014. No. 1 (19), Volume 2. P. 89–98. In Russian
Catherine II. Notes of Empress Catherine II. St. Petersburg: Izdatel’stvo Suvorina, 1907. In Russian
Kostomarov N.I. Russian history in the biographies of its main figures. Second Section: Domination of the House of Romanov before the accession to the throne of Catherine II. Seventh edition: XVIII century. http://dugward.ru/library/kostomarov/kostomarov_rus_ist_2otd_vyp7.html In Russian
Kurukin I.V. The epoch of «court storms»: essays on the political history of post-Petrine Russia (1725–1762). Ryazan, 2003. In Russian
Luzanov P. Land gentry corps under Count Minich (1732–1741). Historical sketch. St. Petersburg, 1907. In Russian
Lystsova A.S. Reform of the cabinet and the Senate of 1741: to the history of political activities of A. I. Osterman and B. Ch. Minich. Vestnik Vyatskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. 2017. No. 3. P. 25–32. In Russian
Minich B.Ch. Report of Field Marshal Minich on the collection and publication of all Russian decrees and regulations, filed on May 14, 1735. Otechestvennyye zapiski, izdavayemyye Pavlom Svin’inym. Part V. St. Petersburg, 1821. P. 265–277. In Russian
Minikh B.Ch. Notes of Field Marshal Count Minich. Ed. by Shubinsky S. N. St. Petersburg: Tip. Bezobrazova i komp, 1874. In Russian
Montesquieu Sh.L. The spirit of the laws. Moscow: Mysl’, 1999. In Russian
Munnich B.Ch. von. Ebauche pour donner une idee de la forme du Gouvernement de l’Empire de Russie. Copenhague, 1774. In French
Nazarova V.D. From «upward message» to memorandum (XVIII – early XX century). Vestnik RGGU. Seriya “Dokumentovedeniye i arkhivovedeniye. Informatika. Zashchita informatsii i informatsionnaya bezopasnost’”. 2014. No. 2 (124). P. 162–168. In Russian
Pavlenko N.I. Drama at the throne. Moscow: RG-Press, 2018. In Russian
Savelyeva E.N. Cabinet of ministers of Empress Anna Ioannovna: dissertation for the degree of candidate of historical sciences. Moscow, 2004. https://www.dissercat.com/content/kabinet-ministrov-imperatritsy-anny-ioannovny In Russian
Sanin O.G. The archive of the government of Peter the Great in the XVIII–XIX centuries. Istoriya i arkhivy. 2008. No. 8. P. 197–213. In Russian
Soloviev A.I. State decisions: the conceptual scope and dead ends of theorizing. Polis. Politicheskiye issledovaniya. 2015. No. 3. P. 127–146. In Russian
Soloviev S.M. Works in 18 books. Book. XI. Moscow: Mysl’. 1993. In Russian
Stroyev V.N. Bironovshhina and Cabinet of ministers. Essays on domestic policies of Empress Anna. Part 1. Moscow, 1909. 206 p.; Part 2. Issue 1. Moscow, 1910. In Russian
The Decree of Empress Anna Ioanovna No. 6745 of June 9, 1735 «On the adoption of a personal Decree only signed by the Imperial hand or three Cabinet Ministers». Complete collection of laws of the Russian Empire. Volume IX. St. Petersburg, 1830. In Russian
The Decree to the Senate No. 8288 «On the establishment of a special Reketmeister at the Imperial Court». Complete collection of laws of the Russian Empire. Volume XI. St. Petersburg, 1830. In Russian
Faizov A.V. The Cabinet of ministers’ collegium (1731–1741). Vestnik Surgutskogo gosudarstvennogo pedagogicheskogo universiteta. 2019. No. 4. P. 26-34. In Russian
Faizov A.V. The governing Senate in 1730–1741: the powers and competencies. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. 2016. No. 4 (35). P. 34–43. In Russian
Filippov A.N. The Cabinet of ministers and its comparison with the Supreme Privy Council. Yuriev, 1898. In Russian
Khmyrov M.D. Feltsikhmeisterstvo of Count Minich // Notes of Field Marshal Count Minich. Ed. by: Shubinsky S. N. St. Petersburg: Tip. Bezobrazova i komp. 1874. In Russian
Articles in Open Access mode are published under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY) license.
